Why Doesn’t God Heal Everyone?



As I read the words from my old journal, I vividly recall my emotions. Shame, humiliation, doubt.

The entry is dated April 16, 1983. The spring semester of my first year in college.

I remember the day well. My friends suggested I go to the meeting, but I was resistant. I had been to healing services before. Each time I had expected a miraculous healing. Each time I believed it would happen. Each time I had returned disappointed.

I wanted to shield myself from further frustration, but at the same time so wanted to be healed.  All day I felt unsettled, vacillating between fear and excitement.

Though we arrived early, the room was packed. The only seats left were in the first row. As we walked to the front of the auditorium, I was painfully aware of my limp. Everyone knew I had come for healing. My presence seemed to intensify the excitement. Were they going to witness a verifiable miracle?

After a short sermon, people started lining up. This travelling evangelist touched people where they were hurting and prayed for them, commanding them to be healed in the name of Jesus. And they all were. Hip pains, ear aches, migraines – all disappeared immediately. For everyone.

My stomach was in knots when someone grabbed my hand and led me onto the stage. There was silence as everyone turned to me. I was terrified.

I sat in a chair while this man pulled on my legs and told me that one leg was longer than the other. He fixed that. Then he touched my shoulders and legs, claimed my healing, and asked me to walk. When I did, nothing was different. He prayed again. Still, no change.

He was irritated. Maybe a bit embarrassed. He looked at me and said, I’ve done all I can do. The rest is up to you.” He walked away, and with a dismissive wave declared “I see that you do not have the faith to be healed. You need to go home and pray and ask God to give you more faith. I’m going to do another healing service and baptism tomorrow. If you have the faith, come to that meeting and you will be healed.”

He turned his attention to the next person in line while my friends helped me off the stage.

I was mortified. No one had ever said it was my fault before. No one had questioned my faith in the process. No one had blamed me for my disability.

I sat there, humiliated, trying to figure out the next step. I was simultaneously embarrassed, insecure, and irate.

Late that night I penned my journal entry. I began with, “I’m so confused and I don’t know what to think…if you want me to be healed Lord, give me the faith.”

Doubts started to overwhelm me. I felt desperate. The following day I wrote, “I have so little faith…you say if we lack faith we must but ask. Lord, I want to be healed…help me to trust that I will be.”

Over the next few days, my emotions were on a roller coaster, alternating between begging God for the faith to be healed and demonizing this man who had humiliated me. I then decided that he was wrong. He was a false teacher. My faith was strong, and no one could question it.

I needed grace. Grace for myself, to see my healing didn’t rest on me. Grace for this man, who was attempting to walk out his gifting. Grace for my friends, who were trying to help me discern truth.

When I was criticized, I arrogantly assumed that no fault lay with me. It was totally his mistake. But few things are that cut and dried, and my sin gets entangled whenever I feel wronged.

At the same time, I don’t believe faith healers can heal whomever the wish. They can only heal those whom God has chosen to restore. That’s the glorious message of the Gospel: God’s plan and promises are not dependent us. He has done it all.

Healing is a bit of a puzzle.

Honestly, I still would love to be physically healed. Or at least for the progression of my post-polio to slow down. It would make my days a lot easier. But God in His wisdom has chosen not to remove this thorn.

I don’t understand when or why God chooses to heal. It remains a mystery. I wish I knew why devout faithful Christians die young of cancer and other not-so-faithful people receive inexplicable healing. When the former are seeking God daily and the latter utter a one-time quick prayer. It doesn’t seem fair.

Yet I’ve received physical healing myself. When I was eight years old, I used ankle braces. The doctors said I couldn’t walk without them. But God changed that in an instant through a faith healer who prayed over me. I haven’t worn braces since and the doctors to this day are astounded. It doesn’t make medical sense.

So why didn’t God go all the way and heal me completely? Why did He just stop with getting rid of my braces? Why didn’t He do the more astonishing miracle?

I don’t know for certain. But I do know that God has done a deeper healing in my life because of my disability. He has taught me to trust Him in the dark. He has refined my character through loss. And He has given me an incredible joy in Him. Those things are more valuable to me than physical healing.

God’s power is being made perfect in my weakness. Paradoxically, it is often in the not being healed, the crying out to God, the trusting Him when it hurts, that I see God most clearly. A Puritan prayer from the book The Valley of Vision, puts it this way:  “Lord, in the daytime, stars can be seen from deepest wells, and the deeper the wells, the brighter thy stars shine.

Though I’d like to understand God’s mysteries, I don’t feel I need to. My finite mind cannot comprehend the Infinite. But I am certain that God is purposeful. That life isn’t random and God isn’t capricious. And whether I am physically healed or not, I can rest on God’s unchanging grace.

The prayer from The Valley of Vision ends with: Let me find thy light in my darkness, thy life in my death, thy joy in my sorrow, thy grace in my sin, thy riches in my poverty, thy glory in my valley.

To which I say, Amen.

photo courtesy of Jonathan Davidar
  • March 21, 2014 - 10:36 am

    Martha - Thank you for being so transparent and for sharing this insight. I think your faith is huge, and I look forward to running along side you in heaven, where you will be whole!ReplyCancel

    • March 21, 2014 - 11:22 am

      Vaneetha - Heaven will be wonderful, won’t it? Looking forward to running in heaven with you, and our glorious cloud of witnesses!ReplyCancel

  • March 26, 2014 - 3:53 pm

    Margot - AUGH!!!!! Your fault?!?! I know that feeling of feeling ASHAMED for not being healed. So sorry you had to endure that.

    Delighted that you share your voice in this space. Thank you.ReplyCancel

    • March 26, 2014 - 4:30 pm

      Vaneetha - Thanks, Margot. It was difficult- but I’ve definitely grown from all my hard things… Though I’m looking for an easier path to sanctification!ReplyCancel

  • April 2, 2014 - 6:34 pm

    Danelle - Amen, my sweet friend. AMEN!!ReplyCancel

  • April 5, 2014 - 8:04 pm

    Linda - Vaneetha
    This quote from Valley of Vision speaks to me today.
    ” Let me find thy light in my darkness, thy life in my death, thy joy in my sorrow, thy grace in my sin, thy riches in my poverty, thy glory in my valley.”
    I sense if we sat across from each other over a cup of tea, it would be a very sweet encounter. I enjoyed reading this today.ReplyCancel

  • July 28, 2014 - 10:16 am

    Carolyn Watts - Beautiful. Thanks, Vaneetha. As a fellow traveller with disability, I echo your discovery. The deeper healing and intimacy God is bringing through my illness is worth far more to me than complete physical healing. Bless you.ReplyCancel

    • July 28, 2014 - 7:50 pm

      Vaneetha - Intimacy with God is a treasure worth trading anything the world has to offer, isn’t it? Thank you for writing, Carolyn.ReplyCancel

  • May 28, 2015 - 5:55 pm

    Job and the Prosperity Gospel - Vaneetha Rendall - […] As I mentioned in a previous post, I have been ushered out the back door at healing services, after being publicly chastised.  I have heard countless similar stories from other disabled people. The assumption is that if you’re not healed, you don’t have enough faith. Because God’s will is for everyone to be healed. Always. The faithful will never suffer. […]ReplyCancel

  • July 8, 2015 - 12:25 pm

    esther kalule - thank you dear…….
    may the Good LORD have mercy upon you and me to deal with our physical disabilitiesReplyCancel

Tweet|Share to Facebook|Subscribe